[Cancelled] Checker Request for GC8JG2K

New Checker Request for GC8JG2K Challenge Cache LBA #5 100/X

Prerequesite to log to above challenge is...

- find 100 letterboxes in total

- including 17 ones, which describes the cross in the d/t-matrix (D5/T5, D4.5/T4.5...D1/T1 and D5/T1, D4.5/T1.5....D1/T5) like in this picture:


- and these 17 ones must have been published by 17 different ownern

Hope to get a workable solution as a checker.
Thx for help.

Best,
hans&grete

Re - and these 17 ones must have been published by 17 different ownern

The criteria is not allowed in a challenge

Please read https://www.geocaching.com/help/index.php?pg=kb.chapter&id=127&pgid=206#criteria

Not acceptable

Quote
These cache page elements: cache titles, cache owner, GC Codes, publishing Reviewer, or cache page text.

I made the checker for you without the last criteria https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GC8JG2K/48402

Please test and reply

What is the situation on this request, feedback please

The cache owner archived GC8JG2K.

As a reviewer, I wouldn't have published it, even after removing the condition about 17 different cache owners. The "X" pattern is a classic example of "Grid Art." This is not a geocaching achievement.

Thanks, I will move this to ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible).

To The Leprechauns
Hi
The "X" pattern is a classic example of "Grid Art." This is not a geocaching achievement.

Can you advise which guideline this would fail to comply with

I think it ticks all the boxes for

*Challenge criteria must be positive and require that a geocaching goal be achieved.
*The challenge requirements should be simple, and easy to explain, follow and document.
*A challenge cache needs to appeal to and be attainable by a reasonable number of cachers.

How is finding 17 caches of a certain type with specific DT criteria NOT a geocaching achievement ?

Thanks