rragan Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Did you get a sense that all bookmark lists would > be unacceptable? Or if the list is some sort of > reference list controlled by others like the > English Church micro list if that would be ok? > Then the list would not be in the primary control > of the CO and not violate #11. I was told specifiby SirKarp - ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible)
I am currently in discussion with one of my local reviewers regarding a checker that uses a bookmark. Though I don't have a definitive answer yet, it does appear as though it would not be approved under guildline #11. Which means the only realistic method would be the cemetery center point method. Doable but a lot of research would be needed. Not sure at this time where I will be goingby SirKarp - ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible)
rragan Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > This might be skirting the intent of the > guidelines and would likely be struck down with a > clarification but right now it does not appear > illegal to base a challenge on finding 50 caches > on a bookmark list. Just put up a list with all > the cemetery caches you can find and more could be >by SirKarp - ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible)
rragan Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > How would you write the challenge description? > Find 50 caches in Washington cemeteries within .2 > miles of these coordinates and then list the 153 > current hides with cemetery in the title, for > example. That sounds pretty weird and I would > think you ought to check with your local reviewer >by SirKarp - ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible)
TravelingGeek Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Unfortunately, the guidelines prohibit the need to > contact the Cache Owner, so I don't think you can > leave it open ended like that. > > Maybe limit it to the counties you have solid data > for? Now that's a thought. I might just have to look into doing it that way, as wellby SirKarp - ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible)
TravelingGeek Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Well, the state of Washington is easy. :) > > Defining the cemeteries is not so easy. Since we > can't look for the word "Cemetery" in cache name > any more. > > IF (and it's a really big IF) you could identify > the center point coordinate of ALL cemeteries (isby SirKarp - ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible)
I've had this challenge in the works before moratorium, now that it has been lifted I'm working on updating it to get it within the new guild lines, obviously part of that is need for a checker. I was hoping to make the requirements as follows. the challenge seeker needs to find 50 cemetery caches within the state of Washington. Of course then the question comes up what defines a cemby SirKarp - ARCHIVE Checker requests (impossible)