Re: GC6JZE2 - Coat of Arms and Map Geo-Art Challenge

Hi folks.

I need a checker for a new challenge cache:
to qualify you must find ALL the caches in Brother Colin's Map of Australia and Coat of Arms Geo-Art.

Cheers.

Please note:

There are 113 caches in the Geo-Art, and at this stage there are still 13 waiting to be published.

This challenge is not publishable: https://support.groundspeak.com/index.php?pg=kb.page&id=206

11. Specific Lists:

Acceptable
A challenge based on caches with at least X number of Favorite Points can be published, as the information comes from Geocaching.com.

Not Acceptable
A challenge based on elements under the cache owner’s primary control is not acceptable: examples, my favorites, my caches, caches by this owner, or this group.

An option might be N caches inside a radius of a point that include the geoarts.

I dont know if that is ok. And how many of the cacher in the area you can include
Ask an rewiever if it is ok

The caches that need to be found to qualify for the Challenge do not belong to me. They are not under my primary control.

I still suspect it would not be allowed.
You say in principal that all caches in list shall be found. That was not allowed even by the old guidelines but was more clear there.

If a checker is created there has to be a bookmarklist or a list of gccodes in the config and those are under your primary control

There is not way to know from caches if it is the geoart from the available data.
The listing text cant be used see guideline 10 "not allowed"

Quote

These listing elements: cache titles, cache owner names, GC Codes, or listing text. (new 2016)

I recommend that you send the challenge to a reviewer and ask if it is according to the guidelines before what i guess is meaningless work i spent on a checker

There is no further feedback from the requester for almost 8 weeks therefore this question will be achieved.
If you still want to pursue the challenge please place a new request.