×

To be able to write in the forum you need to authenticate. Meanwhile it's read-only.

[Awaiting feedback] New Checker Request-GC9K29D supergoober island tribute challenge cache

Hi, this is my first checker request. Any suggestions or recommendations are appreciated. To qualify for this cache you must find and log at least 10 of the 26 caches listed below.

Island caches placed by SuperGoober when this challenge cache was published:

GC21D1 Abby's Treasure Island hidden 10.11.2001

GC1WMJP Cruising Down the River hidden 7.31.2009 archived 08.18.2010

GC1Z5HO Castaway hidden 09.26.2009 archived 10.14.2013

GC2DN0P River Challenge hidden 08.18.2010 archived 07.30.2012

GC2DN3H Crusing Down the River II hidden 08.18.2010 archived 10.05.2019

GC2GVDW Island Girls hidden 10.16.2010 archived 12.31.2015

GC61JZD Wapsipinicon River Island hidden 08.15.2015

GC6N640 Muddy Island hidden 07.09.2016

GC6Q6TH Whale hidden 08.13.2016

GC6Q6T2 Whale Food hidden 08.13.2016

GC6Q6V0 Whale Tail hidden 08.13.2016

GC6Q6TR Whale Belly hidden 08.13.2016

GC6QN9Q Shark Tail hidden 08.21.2016, archived 11.04.2018

GC6QN8W Shark Nose hidden 08.21.2016

GC6QN9P Shark Island hidden 08.21.2016

GC6R0YJ Wapsi Twist Island hidden 08.27.2016

GC6REAQ Lil' Island hidden 09.03.2016

GC6RJ30 Goose Island hidden 09.05.2016

GC74E9T Little Abby hidden 04.22.2017

GC78KM6 Ellis Island hidden 07.08.2017

GC98NDO Deer Island- Deer Tummy hidden 04.03.2021

GC98NCN Deer Island- Deer Head hidden 04.03.2021

GC99K9F Squirrel Tail Island hidden 04.17.2021

GC99MFD Sliver Island hidden 04.18.2021

GC99MNT Break Island hidden 04.18.2021

GC99MHA Snake Tail Island hidden 04.18.2021
Re: New Checker Request-GC9K29D supergoober island tribute challenge cache
December 10, 2021 08:30PM
I'm sorry but this criteria is not allowed

Please read the hiding guidelines 2.12.10. Source of Criteria

Not acceptable
Quote
These cache page elements: cache titles, cache owner, GC Codes, publishing Reviewer, or cache page text.
Re: New Checker Request-GC9K29D supergoober island tribute challenge cache
December 20, 2021 06:12PM
I feel that my proposed cache is in a gray area. I am listing 26 caches, with 20 that are currently active. I am challenging the cacher to locate 10 caches, half of what is currently active. Archived caches can be included.

I am providing the criteria, not asking the cacher to "Find 10 island caches from SuperGoober" which would require the cacher to research SuperGoober. I believe the later is what 2.12.10 is trying to prevent.

I equate my proposed cache to " find X number of oldest caches in the county from a list", or "find X number of a type of cache"

I have meet the requirements of my proposed cache as well.

Any further thoughts are certainly appreciated. I am still learning the nuances as I attempt to publish more caches and would like to find a way to publish this one.
Re: New Checker Request-GC9K29D supergoober island tribute challenge cache
December 20, 2021 08:21PM
Your challenge is based on a selected list of GCcode which is not allowed under 2.12.10
and
2.12.11 tells you that a list under the challenge owner's control is also not acceptable
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login