×

To be able to write in the forum you need to authenticate. Meanwhile it's read-only.

Re: 2 checkers request

[Cancelled] 2 checkers request
February 04, 2024 04:38PM
Hi,

I would like to have 2 checkers related to Geo-birthday

For GCAK7J2, cachers need to find at least 5 caches hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify for the challenge

For GCAK7WM, cachers need to find at least 1 cache hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify for the challenge

I noticed this interesting idea from the thread (https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GCAJX11/85154) and am pleased to know that I have 19 such finds. After checking local cachers, the majority of their numbers are not high. So, I'd like to create 2 different levels of challenge and see how it goes.

Thanks in advance
risumfiriri



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 02/04/2024 04:48PM by risumfiriri. (view changes)
Re: 2 checkers request
February 04, 2024 05:39PM
Here are for
For GCAK7J2, cachers need to find at least 5 caches hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify for the challenge
https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GCAK7J2/85433
For GCAK7WM, cachers need to find at least 1 cache hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify for the challenge
https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GCAK7WM/85432

but don't be surprised if the reviewer is not accepting this challenge criteria.
A lot of reviewers find the criteria time-limited
Re: 2 checkers request
February 05, 2024 12:41AM
Dear vogelbird,

I tested the checkers and the results are not what I need. Sorry for not making my requests clear.
I want to check the caches whose hidden day just match the joining day of a cacher.

Like the checker in this thread (https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GCAJX11/85154)

My joining day is 02-20 and the result is

Quote

risumfiriri (https://www.geocaching.com/profile/?u=risumfiriri) has used Project-GC (https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GCAJX11/85154) to see if they qualified for this challenge and they did.

Success! risumfiriri found 19 caches on a Geo Birthday: Account Creation Date:2013-02-20 
GC96FZF (http://coord.info/GC96FZF) RS100:Manka Longshan Temple / 艋舺龍山寺 (Traditional Cache) 2021-02-20 
GC7JJBJ (http://coord.info/GC7JJBJ) [Last Wall] (Traditional Cache) 2018-02-20 
GC7JJC5 (http://coord.info/GC7JJC5) [Bright City] (Traditional Cache) 2018-02-20 
GC83RBZ (http://coord.info/GC83RBZ) Happiness is... Into the Sea! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83RBY (http://coord.info/GC83RBY) Happiness is... Lego Bricks! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83RBX (http://coord.info/GC83RBX) Happiness is... Treasure Box! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83RC0 (http://coord.info/GC83RC0) Happiness is... Express Train! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83RC1 (http://coord.info/GC83RC1) Happiness is... Rainbow! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83RC2 (http://coord.info/GC83RC2) Happiness is... Monkey! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83RC3 (http://coord.info/GC83RC3) Happiness is... Floating Bridge! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83RC4 (http://coord.info/GC83RC4) Happiness is... No.1! (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83R8K (http://coord.info/GC83R8K) Jinlong Temple 金龍禪寺 (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC96FYX (http://coord.info/GC96FYX) TaipeiCity MappingControlPoint-BA006 / 台北市美化控制點 (Unknown Cache) 2021-02-20 
GC2P523 (http://coord.info/GC2P523) The City of Tigers (Traditional Cache) 2011-02-20 
GC83R8T (http://coord.info/GC83R8T) Ciyun Temple 慈雲宮 (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC83R8E (http://coord.info/GC83R8E) No name creek side 無名溪畔 (Traditional Cache) 2019-02-20 
GC96EYB (http://coord.info/GC96EYB) TaipeiCity MappingControlPoint-BA005 / 台北市美化控制點 (Unknown Cache) 2021-02-20 
GC7JKKY (http://coord.info/GC7JKKY) Tudigong shrine with two names (Traditional Cache) 2018-02-20 
GC7JKGJ (http://coord.info/GC7JKGJ) Ying Ge Shi Shan / 鶯歌石山 (Traditional Cache) 2018-02-20
Thank you so much for your time
risumfiriri
Re: 2 checkers request
February 05, 2024 04:14AM
In that case
GCAK7WM, cachers need to find at least 1 cache hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify for the challenge
https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GCAK7WM/85445

But GCAK7J2, cachers need to find at least 5 caches hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify for the challenge this is not allowed

Please read https://www.geocaching.com/help/index.php?pg=kb.chapter&id=127&pgid=206#timeLimited

Not acceptable
Quote
Requiring more than one find on any day or calendar date, even if cumulative.
Re: 2 checkers request
February 05, 2024 07:35AM
vogelbird Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> In that case
> GCAK7WM, cachers need to find at least 1 cache
> hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify for the
> challenge
> https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GCAK7WM/85445
>
> But GCAK7J2, cachers need to find at least 5
> caches hidden on their geo-birthdays to qualify
> for the challenge this is not allowed
>
> Please read
> https://www.geocaching.com/help/index.php?pg=kb.chapter&id=127&pgid=206#timeLimited
>
> Not acceptable
Quote
Requiring more than one
> find on any day or calendar date, even if
> cumulative.

>
>

Unless I'm misunderstanding here, the first part (the cache description) is about hidden date and the second part (the guideline) is about find date. To achieve five finds from the same hidden date doesn't mean that you are required to make multiple finds on any given date. Or am I missing something in the descriptions above?
Re: 2 checkers request
February 05, 2024 07:49AM
Dear vogelbird,

Thank you so much for detailed explanation.
The first part (GCAK7WM) is great.
I'll modify my criteria for GCAK7J2 and resubmit a new request.

Regards,
Re: 2 checkers request
February 05, 2024 09:56AM
Apologies for messing you about but you are right, for hidden dates it is allowed to have more then one day.

Would you still like the 5 caches on hidden or are you going for the new criteria???
Re: 2 checkers request
February 04, 2024 10:19PM
Thank you, vogelbird.
I will test these checkers as soon as possible. And many thanks for additional information.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login