Re: Retry to The monthly CITO-attender

Hello!

I few days ago I got quick help with this:

To have attended at least one CITO-event every month of the year.
All countries are to be valid.

It would be great if if the output showed an calender of some kind with the found/unfound months.

https://coord.info/GC7F82Z

The checker that was written was this one:
https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GC7F82Z/30323

But now the reviewer says that this is an streak and that limiting to an specified cache type therefore is against the guidelines.

But there are no streak involved in the task from my point of view. Or is there?
The checker only looks for finds in all months, without any order among them.

So before I make an appeal I want to ask for opinions from you script/tag writers if this challenge is OK according the the current guidelines or not?

Best regards
Peter-tvm

This is not the wright checker , here is a new one https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GC7F82Z/30484

If you are happy with this checker I will delete the other one

Both checkers seems fine to me. But if the first one was the wrong one I will use the one given by vogelbird.

The question about the challenge being an streak remains.
Or should I answer the reviewer that since the experienced tag writers saw nothing wrong with the task it ought to be OK according the the guidelines?

You can see in your results that this is not a streak there are differents attend years
[peter-tvm](https://www.geocaching.com/profile/?u=peter-tvm) has used [Project-GC](https://project-gc.com/Challenges/GC7F82Z/30484 "Project-GC Challenge Checker") to see if he/she qualified for this challenge and he/she did.

Type: **Cache In Trash Out Event** (12)
01 - GC5HY6J / Inga raketer på Midgård / 2015-01-01
02 - GC68TZ8 / Värnrensning / 2016-02-29
03 - GC4XTGY / Städa upp Norrbackas skogsdunge / 2014-03-01
04 - GC4ZKYR / CITO #1 GCU 2014 / 2014-04-26
05 - GC4VFT2 / Burudvann Cito / 2014-05-03
06 - GC56X5K / Cleaning of Longyearbyens Rocky beach / 2014-06-30
07 - GC57TVD / CITO - Himos / 2014-07-13
08 - GC5ZGTM / Gnista pendlarparkerings-CITO / 2015-08-01
09 - GC6Q2MD / Gnista pendlarparkerings-CITO IV / 2016-09-17
10 - GC63H0H / Rastplatsstädning / 2015-10-31
11 - GC65H3Y / CITO - Rastplats E16 / 2015-11-14
12 - GC67N26 / Nu stundar ett nytt år / 2015-12-31

Thanks, I will give it one more try with the reviewer.

I'd suggest rewording it to be clear:
To have attended a CITO in every calendar month (regardless of year).

I think the reviewer probably misinterpretted the original phrasing to mean you have to attend in every month of a particular calendar year (which would be a streak).